Back to top arrow

Prime Storage

2091 New Highway, Farmingdale, NY 11735

Prime Storage in New Highway

Prime Storage offers clean, secure, and affordable self storage units in a variety of sizes to fit your needs, whether you're moving, decluttering, running a business, or storing seasonal items. Many of our locations also offer climate controlled units and vehicle storage for cars, boats, RVs, and motorcycles. Month-to-month leases, online account access, and friendly local teams make storing with Prime easy. When Life Demands Space, Prime Storage is here to help.

Read moreRead less

Type:

Select Size:

Select Amenity:

Small
5' x 5' storage unit
5' x 5' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$41.00
Web Rate:
$24.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 5' storage unit
5' x 5' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$79.00
Web Rate:
$48.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 5' storage unit
5' x 5' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$99.00
Web Rate:
$59.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 10' storage unit
5' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$98.00
Web Rate:
$68.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 10' storage unit
5' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$106.00
Web Rate:
$74.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 6' storage unit
5' x 6' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Alarm
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$125.00
Web Rate:
$86.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 10' storage unit
5' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$136.00
Web Rate:
$114.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
5' x 10' storage unit
5' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$143.00
Web Rate:
$119.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Medium
10' x 10' storage unit
10' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$169.00
Web Rate:
$140.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Medium
10' x 10' storage unit
10' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • Upper Floor
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$187.00
Web Rate:
$157.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Small
20' storage unit
20' Outside Parking
  • PARKING
  • Car, Boat, RV
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$191.00
Web Rate:
$173.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Medium
10' x 10' storage unit
10' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • FIRST MONTH FREE
Store Rate
$204.00
Web Rate:
$187.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Medium
10' x 10' storage unit
10' x 10' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$235.00
Web Rate:
$198.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Large
10' x 15' storage unit
10' x 15' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$335.00
Web Rate:
$275.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Large
10' x 20' storage unit
10' x 20' Unit
  • Climate Controlled
  • Indoor
  • First Floor Access
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$394.00
Web Rate:
$379.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Large
10' x 20' storage unit
10' x 20' Unit
  • Outside Unit
  • First Floor
  • ACT FAST: LIMITED UNITS.
Store Rate
$595.00
Web Rate:
$496.00
SelectClose
No Credit Card Required
Prime Storage - Limited Availability
Reserve for FREE! (855) 596-7884
Call now, let us help you find a unit and save!

Facility Hours

Office Hours

  • Mon:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
  • Tue:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
  • Wed:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
  • Thu:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
  • Fri:10:00 AM - 06:00 PM
  • Sat:10:00 AM - 04:00 PM
  • Sun:CLOSED -

Access Hours

  • Mon:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Tue:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Wed:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Thu:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Fri:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sat:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM
  • Sun:06:00 AM - 10:00 PM

Facility Amenities

  • Cash Accepted
  • Checks Accepted
  • Credit Cards Accepted
  • Moving Supplies
  • Vehicle Required Title
  • Vehicle Requires Insurance
  • Vehicle Requires Registration
  • Handcarts and Dollies
  • Online Bill Pay
  • Automatic Payments
  • Online Payments

Facility Map

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Prime Storage at 2091 New Highway has first floor or ground floor storage?

A ground floor storage unit at 2091 New Highway makes it easier to access and does not require the use of an elevator. However, the convenience of a first floor storage unit usually comes with a cost, and are typically more expensive.

What is elevator access or an upper floor storage unit?

An elevator access storage unit makes it a little more difficult to load and unload your storage unit and requires the use of an elevator or stair case. However, a upper floor storage unit typically will be less expensive.

What is a storage locker?

A storage locker has a reduced ceiling height between 4 to 6 feet. These storage units are good for storing small items; like suit cases, small household items, school and dormitory items, office supplies or holiday decorations. Storage lockers are usually less expensive than other units and could be the ground floor or accessed with a rolling ladder.

What is an onsite storage manager?

The manager of the storage facility actually lives in an apartment that is typically attached to the storage facility. The storage unit tenants get a feeling of security, knowing that a manager is nearby to address emergency matters or other matters that could occur after hours.

Does Prime Storage, 2091 New Highway offer extended hours?

Yes, Prime Storage at 2091 New Highway offers extended hours. Usually storage facility office hours are 9:00 am to 6:00 pm. Extended hours could be from 6:00 am to 10:00 pm or even 24 hours a day, giving storage tenants more access to their storage unit.

What is keypad access?

A keypad entrance storage facility at 2091 New Highway will control who enters and exits the facility. The tenant is provided a personal gate code and prevents non renters from entering the gated property.

What is the difference between a roll up door and a swing door?

A roll up door provides a larger opening and rolls into the ceiling of the storage unit. Where as a swing door, opens to the outside and swing door is more like a large residential house door. Larger units and newer construction will offer more roll up doors.

What items should you NOT put in a storage unit at 2091 New Highway?

Most, if not all storage facilities prohibit the storing of food, live animals, explosive materials, weapons, ammunition, stolen merchandise, motorized vehicles that are not registered or insured.

Do self storage facilities in Farmingdale sell boxes and packing supplies?

Most storage facilities in Farmingdale offer locks, different box sizes, packing tape, bubble wrap, covers for furniture and numerous other packing supplies.

What are the most common unit sizes at 2091 New Highway

The most common unit sizes at Prime Storage in 2091 New Highway are 5x5 and 10x10. Most facilities also have other unit sizes available such as 5x`0, 10x20 and even 10x30 unit sizes.

Are the storage units at 2091 New Highway secure?

All storage units at 2091 New Highway are secure and protected at all times. Prime Storage in Farmingdale is backed by security features such as video surveillance, security access to your unit only and electronic gate access.

Facility Reviews

PR

June 27th, 2025- From Sf

I recently signed up for a storage unit at the Farmingdale location and had an outstanding experience, thanks to James. From the very beginning, he was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and patient throughout the entire process. He took the time to answer all of my questions thoroughly and provided a detailed overview of the facility. James even walked me through the building, showing me the entrance, elevator, and taking me all the way to my unit on the second floor. Along the way, he pointed out everything I needed to know, making the entire experience seamless and stress-free. His friendliness and professionalism were truly appreciated. The facility itself is easy to find, convenient location spotless—clean, odor-free, and cool. My unit was in perfect condition: great location, perfect size, and exceptionally clean. I’m beyond satisfied with both the service and the facility and would highly recommend Prime Storage in Farmingdale to anyone in need of storage solutions.

片来

April 30th, 2025- From Sf

This is not good that I don't have an option to not put stuff jere

John

November 3rd, 2024- From Sf

Facility allows easy access to storage unit… full size dolies make moving boxes easier.

patrick gonzalez

October 17th, 2024- From Sf

Great experience and reasonable price.

Ashley Singh

August 31st, 2024- From Sf

Please fix the ramp near the elevator

浩步

July 19th, 2024- From Sf

Location seems like it is clean and secure

Justin Zorn

January 2nd, 2024- From Sf

Just rented one month here first month was free it only cost me $29.99

Winonah

December 3rd, 2023- From Sf

The person who helps me is so good of what he is doing. He find a storage that fits my needs in a low price.Sparefoot is a good place to go to find self-storage that fits your budget and needs.

Holly Bailey

June 24th, 2023- From Sf

I was looking for a place to store my RV. I called and left a message. I received a phone call back very quickly. I went to the facility. It had exactly what I was looking for. The paperwork was completed quickly and easily, mostly thanks to Venus! She knew exactly what she was doing. No problems. I am happy I found this place.

Chris N.

March 19th, 2023- From Sf

I moved items to a storage locker yesterday. Received a warm, friendly welcome from Venus. She also assisted with guiding me through the facility.